Another NOT EDNA PURVIANCE, as Jessica Buxton shared an image she found in the new book 'Charlie Chaplin' by Peter Ackroyd (released May 2014).
The photo marked (A) shows Charlie Chaplin, but NOT with Edna Purviance, as the caption reads in Ackroyd's book, but with Raquel Meller. And the year wasn't 1918, but 1926. In picture (B), Chaplin and Meller were photographed for the Los Angeles Times on the Circus set, at Chaplin's studio in the summer of 1926 (image B).
Special image created by ednapurviance.org
Chaplin had one of his instant attraction to Meller, and even wanted to cast her in his NAPOLEON film. While nothing came of that, Chaplin did use the song Meller helped make famous, "LA VIOLETERA," for his music for the blind girl theme in 'City Lights.' Chaplin never credited the composer, leading people to think "LA VIOLETERA" was his own creation. The composer, José Padilla Sánchez, sued Chaplin, and won his lawsuit against Chaplin for using his music uncredited.
As for the caption, it's another example of people not knowing what Edna Purviance looks like. It's easy to see it is NOT Edna, by face features and hair colour alone. What's more puzzling, is how the author came to the conclusion this was Edna.
Thanks, Jessica, for sharing this. Just want people to know, if you have this book, and you see this image, it is NOT Edna Purviance.
After nearly a decade of court battles, and trying to find a new owner, Grand View Cemetery has been sold. The Heritage Cemetery Management Inc. purchased the Glendale cemetery in May 2014.
Currently, the cemetery is having some upgrades, with future plans for more improvements. The cemetery first opened in 1890. It ran into serious problems leading to a lawsuit in 2005. Time will tell what the future of the cemetery will be, but at least it is beginning a new start.
Grand View is the final resting place for several films stars, including Edna Purviance.
Just letting fans know, I learned today from Diana Calado, my FAKE Walk of Fame Star, for the Edna Purviance Walk of Fame petition drive, was used in a book about Charlie Chaplin, saying Edna has a star.
Edna DOES NOT have a star on the Walk of Fame, and these people never read the site or never followed up, to learn the information behind this star. They just took it and published it.
So, letting my followers and fans know, this is my fake star, and I had NOTHING to do with the publisher of the book, who took my image and published it with false information on Edna. Thanks very much to Diana Calado, for informing me about this today...
Joao Antônio Franz dos Santos has created this wonderful comparison video showing the official release of THE PILGRIM (as Charlie Chaplin had last edited it for The Chaplin Revue in the late 1950s) and a much earlier Russian version released closer to the original silent version.
Don't know the exact year of the Russia version, but could have been an original silent version released with sound during the 1930s, since the frame isn't as wide. But Joao was going through his collection and re-discovered it, so can't remember when he got it, but decided to make this comparison to show the differences.
Sample from Joao's comparison, showing Edna & Charlie in scene not in the any official version.
The Russian version is not restored, but putting that aside, you'll see totally different takes, more close ups, scenes not seen anywhere else, changes in speed, and general different feel of Charlie's character, that Chaplin edited together in the earlier version. I and others, have seen a more gentle version of Charlie's character in his last edited films, over his earlier edited films during his career. (I did a report on The Kid a few years ago.)
I personally enjoy seeing these earlier versions, because it tells me more about Chaplin during his filmmaking years, over the period he was retired and re-editing his work for a modern audience. He shifted his character to being more gentle and polite in his later edits, every chance he got. I have now seen the same change in The Kid, Shoulder Arms, Pay Day and now The Pilgrim. (Should say, also love the silent version of The Gold Rush, over the narrative one in the 1940s.) Just something more real about this character in his earlier edits.
Chaplin also was more balanced in showing the other characters he played with. To me, he seemed to refocused the last edits toward himself more, and removed bits to whole backgrounds of the other characters. (I thought Jackie had some of his best scenes in an earlier version of The Kid, but could say the same for some of Chaplin's scenes, as well.) Great film in both, but love the earlier version as Charlie's character seems more real, and not as polished. The best thing I like about the last edited films is the music, but really like the earlier versions for the character and story.
These films were released by Chaplin since he owned the copyright from 1918 onward, so he approved of both, just in different eras. Just love seeing the earlier Chaplin, when he was in his prime years and seeing films his peer audiences saw. Thanks to Joao for making this comparison. Great study!
Also has scenes not seen of Edna Purviance in other versions, which is great for Edna's fans!
Comparison created by Joao Antônio Franz dos Santos
'The Forgotten Films Roscoe "Fatty" Arbuckle' - DVD collection
Producer by Laughsmith Entertainment and Mackinac Media
Special Warning for those who own or thinking of buying the 'The Forgotten Films Roscoe "Fatty" Arbuckle' DVD collection. If you have this collection, you should check your disc. This morning I found all four of my DVDs in this collection defective.
Only Volumes 1 and 4 were still playing, but Volumes 2 and 3 could not be read by the player. Above looking at the disc, I found all four with the lamination appearing to be dissolving off the disc.
If thinking of ordering, I wouldn't. But if you still want to try, contact the seller and tell them you learned of a serious problem with the disc lamination. Get a guarantee of return if your discs are defective.
View of Disc Two that will not play and cannot be read.
These were released in 2005. It could be a case of poor quality DVD disc that are aging, but would like to know if any other people are having this same issue.
I can say, what I saw in the Volume 1 and 4 were great fun to see, but VERY disappointed the disc quality is so poor. Sorry to say, but if you really want to see it, try finding it through you local library - maybe through interlibrary loan - and save your money.
To all creator/producers of DVD products: I don't know the situation with these, but as a buyer, I would like to see these burned on the best blanks available, not the lowest quality ones to save money. This is a waste for the buyer and seller.
UPDATE: A solution from Bill (who commented here, and Rainer Mann, from my Edna's page).
Here is a video to explain. It may help you if your disc look the same...
Update August 25, 2014 - Just had another fan find their Fatty disc with the same problem! (see picture). On top of that, they learned their 90th Edition Chaplin Mutuals they bought in 2006, has the same issue. Check your collections today! If you have the same problems with any of your disc, post below. Thanks. See video and comments for tips to clean this flaking off.
Added note: I had another fan write in that their full collection of the Dallas TV series looked just like this. Their disc would not play, so they ended up washing them. So the problem is beyond just silent film collections.
Update August 25, 2014 - Just checked around and found another one who had the same problem:
A reminder! August 14th, TCM will be airing a full day of Charlie Chaplin films and documentaries. It's the first 24 hours of Chaplin they have had in quite a while. So mark your calendar for a day with Charlie and Edna!
First off, very sorry for the lack of post here but certainly working on Edna's family bio.
It has been an off and on project for several months due to work, family, projects, weather too hot for office, etc. But, being caught up, I have been writing steady this month. So far, I have rewrite my First National section, and closer to getting the full draft printed for the section. It's a slow project in writing, but its moving along at least.
Meanwhile, here is an amateur film created by Ralph Barton from about 1926. It includes many people, including Barton friend, Charles Chaplin.
Since the late 1990s, the Chaplin Museum has been in the planning stages to be created, but now appears to be firmly in place to have the go ahead to complete. Located at his Swiss home, the new opening date is in 2016.
The latest restored edition of the 12 'Chaplin's Mutual Comedies' are finally being released by Flicker Alley. This is the US version of the earlier French edition from Arte (La Naissance de Charlot).
Released by Flicker Alley and Blackhawk Films, this collection is being released for a limited time in a collector's edition SteelBook Case at a pre-release price of $39.95 plus shipping. The case will contain both the DVD and Blu-Ray disc.
Another feature is the choice of viewing the films with full orchestral or improvised piano. The list of composers included: Eric Beheim, Neil Brand, Timothy Brock, Antonio Coppola, Carl Davis, Stephen Horne, Robert Israel, the Mont Alto Motion Picture Orchestra, Maud Nelissen, Donald Sosin, and Gabriel Thibaudeau.
The special price is available until *July 29, 2014. (*Price likely will change before that date, if released earlier.) So, if interested, best to pre-order now. As most fans know these collections do get expensive. This one will list for $59.95, plus shipping, after release.
Very sorry for being quiet over here, but I have been placing every free block of time into writing Edna's family bio. I have been doing new research as I go long, in trying to gather as much material from that era as possible. I'm well into the film years in the draft, but continue to find things that cause me to pause and rewrite sections. It's a great deal of fun, so thankfully, I don't think of it as work, but an adventure!
I haven't been surfing much on the web, but at times run into some nice things I like to share here. For those who haven't seen these, here are some videos provided by the Oscars sharing moments from the 2011, Summer of Silents series.
The first one is Kevin Brownlow speaking about 'The General.'
If you never have been to Cottage Grove, Oregon to see the town Buster Keaton filmed 'The General,' this is one video to see before going. John Bengston's continues his great work in finding the locations of where films were shot. This is a really good detailed look at 'The General' Cottage Grove locations.
If you do visit, stop in at the visitor center on Main Street, just west of the Hotel that Buster is painted on. They have a book about the filming, but be warned. When I was there, they were out of stock. (Interestingly, not everyone is as up on Buster in Cottage Grove, as we found out last year. So this video really helps in enjoying your visit.)
Silent child star, Diana Serra Cary, sharing some moments on her career. Especially when the talkies begun.
And a short bit about scoring for 'The Covered Wagon'. (I have the VHS of this film, and recommend the film. Hopefully, it will be on DVD one day. So far, not. It is one that should be done properly.)
Back to writing...
PS - Thanks everyone, for the continued support of The Sea Gull, as more copies have been going out, especially to Europe and the UK. New stock in place, ready to ship!